Rand v. Eyemart Express, LLC
Optical chain; Fifth Circuit decision pending on whether pixel data is PHI.
Class action
Appeal pending
Secondary source
Last verified Sep 8, 2026
Appeal pending
Secondary source
Last verified Sep 8, 2026
The matter
- Matter ID
- SND-0205
- Organization
- Eyemart Express
- Location
- Farmers Branch, Texas
- Provider type
- Specialty practice
- Court
- N.D. Tex.; Fifth Circuit
- Docket
- 3:24-cv-621-N
Timeline
- Filed
- 2024
- Key ruling
- May 27, 2025
Key ruling
Dismissed with prejudice: no PHI pleaded; one-party consent. Fifth Circuit argued Mar. 30, 2026; decision pending.
Status note
DISMISSED with prejudice May 27, 2025 (no PHI pleaded; one-party consent); appeal argued in the Fifth Circuit Mar. 30, 2026 — decision pending. | Fifth Circuit decision pending — first appellate ruling on the PHI question in a pixel case.
Exposure
Pages covered Public website (unauthenticated)
Tracking technologies named
Source
Law-firm blog Firm page
Data licensed under CC BY 4.0. Cite as SounderData.com Tracker Litigation Database, September 11, 2026.